I?ve found this thread to be very interesting. Earlier there was some discussion about the idea that herding dogs were ?quirky and ballistic?. Maybe you would like to hear from someone who bought into this idea for a while. When I first started looking for a border collie, I looked at AKC dogs because that was my background in dogs. (Many years ago I worked for a lady who bred and successfully showed German Shepherd Dogs.) So I talked to show people. I found a breeder who had dogs with beautiful temperaments, which is what I was most interested in. She had sheep on her property, and she had all these lovely, furry, black and white, friendly dogs. So I put my name on her list and waited for a puppy. Meanwhile, I read about border collies online and in books, and found this board. I began to get a feel for the ?right? way to breed good working dogs (although it took me a while). What I did get early on, from almost all sources, was the idea that working-bred border collies WERE NOT FOR EVERYONE. I totally understand why almost everyone puts this disclaimer first when someone says they want a border collie. It is something that needs to be said. But in my case, I started thinking ?Well, maybe I NEED something a little ?watered down?. I?m not going to be herding sheep. I want to do a little obedience, maybe some agility, and I REALLY need my dog to be good with my kids and with their friends. I certainly don?t need to have a dog who herds them into a corner and won?t let them out.? So the really sweet, fluffy dogs looked about right. As I said, I bought into the ?quirky and ballistic? thing. So when a puppy became available from the show breeder, I took him, even though I was starting to feel a little guilty about getting an AKC dog. In the year and a half we?ve had him, he has been nearly everything I hoped for, and where he isn?t, it?s my lack, not his. So I?m not sorry we got him. But I?ve kept reading these boards (and Thank You to everyone for much excellent advice!) and if I were in the market for a second dog, I would go to a working breeder or perhaps try rescue again. But the point of this long ramble is that I was frightened away from the working-bred dogs by the very people who loved them the most! I guess the intent is to steer the unprepared toward an ?easier? breed, but I just went part way away, to AKC. I wonder if this happens to others as well? Or maybe I?m just realllly slow at catching on?.
Tracey